Bought this after trying one of the "gummy" rail protectors and am so glad we did! The gummy protector did a decent job of protecting the crib from kids biting them, but it started coming off after about a year and left an awful sticky residue along the entire crib rail.
Decided to try this fleece rail cover and LOVE it! It covers the entire rail, ties on easily and securely (we use square knots so it's easy to take off and toss in the washer), looks nice in the nursery, and protects the crib (and our child's teeth!)
The fleece on top is soft and the waterproof bottom protects the rail from drooling. Only wish we'd found this sooner!
Click below to buy it at Amazon:
Trend Lab CribWrap Fleece Rail Cover for Long Rail, Natural, Wide
Update: June 2014
We've now used this for 2 children and it still looks new! Does a great job of protecting the crib and I love how nice it looks and how easy it is to wash. We hang it to dry (or dry on low) to help keep it's shape.
